The Deleted Photograph — Mauro Magagna and Yuri Santini

There is a photograph I cannot show.
I took it more than twenty years ago. It was a photograph of a deer, completely out of focus.
At the time, I was mainly involved in the world of nature photography. I showed the image to some photographer friends. We discussed it, and in the end they convinced me that it didn’t work. Or, to put it less elegantly, that it was crap.
I deleted it.

I can’t say today whether it was a good photograph. It probably wasn’t. But among the thousands of technically correct images I made during those years, that deleted photograph is one of the ones I still remember.
Perhaps because it contained a question that, at the time, I didn’t yet know how to formulate.
A Question
During the years of photography forums, I used to spend time on Asferico, an important meeting place for people involved in nature photography.
That was where I met Mauro Magagna, who used the name Menti Roventi on the forum.
Mauro is no longer with us, but that question and the memory of our encounters have remained with me.

Mauro was quite a character. He posted photographs that broke many of the conventions we had learned to consider correct.
Some looked as though they were stained with blood, others appeared deliberately disordered.
He criticized a certain tendency in nature photography to produce images that all looked alike, which he provocatively called figurine — “little pictures.”
I wanted to meet him.
We met in Parma, roughly halfway between Bologna and Verona. Mauro brought some very large prints with him.


Seeing them physically was a surprise.
It wasn’t only the photograph: there was the presence of the object, its size, and a rough, tactile paper that particularly struck me. I worked in the production of art books and already had a professional sensitivity to paper and printing.
In photography, however, at the time I was mostly accustomed to smooth surfaces designed to reproduce the greatest possible sharpness.
During one of our conversations, Mauro asked me a question that I have never forgotten:
Are nature photographs beautiful because the subject is beautiful, or because the photographs themselves are beautiful?
It didn’t mean that we should stop photographing an animal or a spectacular landscape.
The question was something else.

An animal’s behaviour, the place where it lives, its relationship with what surrounds it — all of these could become part of the photograph.
The subject did not necessarily have to exhaust everything the image could contain.

Some time later, Mauro invited me to his home in Verona for dinner with a few friends. That evening I met Yuri Santini.
Yuri lives with his partner Matilde in a small village in Trentino and devotes much of his time to outdoor experiences, hiking, climbing and places far from the most travelled routes.
He had known Mauro long before I did and, looking at his photographs, I had the feeling that he had already transformed into images many of the questions Mauro was asking me.
That evening I felt small.

Not out of envy. I simply found myself in front of people whom I considered further along the photographic path I wanted to follow.
Mauro had left me with a question. In Yuri, I could see one of the possible answers.
And I felt an urgency to change beginning to grow.
Today, I would remove one word from Mauro’s question.
I would simply say:
Are photographs beautiful because the subject is beautiful, or because the photographs themselves are beautiful?
Because over the years I have come to understand that this question is not only about nature.
Special thanks for kindly providing the images. Mauro Magagna and Yuri Santini my dearest friends

Commenti